Soo................who is your pick?

[R.D.]

Bradford
McCoy
Tebow
Harrell


seems to me there are enough people tooting that Tebow should get it for a back to back trophy......I call BS cause there hasn't been much he hasn't done this year compared to last year's stats......unless you listen to the Gator-ades......he has only had 2 outstanding games this year....1 against Miami with 256yds pass & the other with 319 against Miss that they lost to by one point. rest of them have been a sub-par passing against decent teams.......but I am sure he could put up higher numbers against a couple other teams...............unless being almost 1000 yds short from last year counts

Of coarse.......the B-12 has 3 candidates in there & they don't like that


Personally....I like the way Bradford has played this year.....even with the loss to Texas he still managed to put up 387yd on there Defense


BUT.......my overall pick has to go to Harrell I think
that guy has put it up now.......over 4700 yds this year alone & did 5700 last year .............not to mention being his final season and has has over 15000 yds in career


so lets here it

[caseysmith14]

.... Freeman

[R.D.]

not one of my choices......but I dont ok

[BuzzChamp]

If Bradford has a good game in the 12 Champ game say 300yds and no pics and a win I think he wins it. If he lose the 12 or has a bad game, it is Harrell, then Tebow.

[PII Magnum]

Reesing all the way

I think McCoy will win it

[R.D.]

man.................you guys & your WILD cards


OK....lets narrow it down to the remaining top 5 picks

[BuzzChamp]

I think McCoy will win it [/QUOTE]

With all of Mac Brown's crying over the 12 south winner, they my give it to McCoy as empathy trophy.

[R.D.]

[PII Magnum]

[Rodney Bledsoe]

Bradford it's all politics

[R.D.]

Yeah.....I know it is Rodney...............but could you just imagine if it wasnt

[TimS]

What would those other QBs numbers look like it put into the TTU system???? My guess is very similar. Harrell's stats are too inflated by their system to get me excited about him. I say Bradford, I can't pull for McCoy after seeing him crumble two years in a row to our crummy defense...

[BUCOBasser]

Tebow will win it. The press has been touting him for years and the SEC has always contolled it. I think that McCoy should win and will show it once he hits the pros. When he's on his game though Herrell is awesome.

[War Eagle1]

<TABLE WIDTH="90%" CELLSPACING=0 CELLPADDING=0 ALIGN=CENTER><TR><TD>Quote, originally posted by cgs2004 &raquo;</TD></TR><TR><TD CLASS="quote">.... Freeman </TD></TR></TABLE>

[R.D.]

I can agree with the system to a certain degree but how would Harrell's stats be inflated?

not claiming I know enough about that to say anything but what do you mean exactly? if a guy passes for 400 yards in a game doe sthat mean he only passed for less than that? or if he has 4700 yards on a season averaging about 390 per game.....has been rushed & still seem to have decent games with an abover average of 70% completion rate.....has had games in 80%'s.......and has driven a team to a 11-1 season

[OzarkBassin]

As much as it disgusts me, my money's on Tebow with McCoy second and Bradford 3rd, Harrel 4th.

My preference, if I were voting, would be McCoy, Bradford, Herrel, Tebow. Tebow's unrefined, but a heck of an overall QB, McCoy is the whole package.

[Hydrilla Gorilla]

Colt McCoy, Texas: After watching him run for two touchdowns and pass for two more against Texas A&M I'm convinced there's no player more valuable to his team than McCoy. His performance boosted his statistics -- a team-leading 576 rushing yards, 10 rushing TDs, 3,445 passing yards, 32 touchdown passes against seven interceptions and 4,021 yards of total offense. He doesn't have the collection of receivers or the running game around him that Sam Bradford does. But his place on my ballot is tenuous, because his next two challengers both are playing this week for championships while he watches.