There has been a lot of talk about these valves lately. Should water be coming into the livewell when in the "Empty" position? My understanding is that it should not and only allow water to drain OUT. That being said my 2015 lets water in on "Empty" in addition my friend's brand new 2017 let water in as well in the E position the first day on the water. If I am not going to use the wells I will put the valve in "Recirc" and they will stay dry.