NCAA Playoff Ranking

[Meadows]

Ok… gimme your spread against the top ten, prove they’re in the top 4. Or use the 12 team format…they play Liberty first game, should win, then what

That's why they play the game man. That's the whole point I'm trying to prove, if it's all speculation then why play the game? If FSU is so bad, then why did they fall to a 5 seed and not a 10 seed, 12 seed?

Look at the NCAAM tournament. How many times has there been a Final Four of all one seeds?

[HawkDriver]

That's why they play the game man. That's the whole point I'm trying to prove, if it's all speculation then why play the game? If FSU is so bad, then why did they fall to a 5 seed and not a 10 seed, 12 seed?

Look at the NCAAM tournament. How many times has there been a Final Four of all one seeds?

Basketball / Baseball not even kind of a comparison. I can find JUCO’s in Cali / Texas / Fl that will hurt a lot of teams feelings. They put two dismal performances while wins on tape with no chance of Travis returning. The rankings frankly don’t matter after 4 and FSU got probably if we’re being honest the 1 or 2 seed in a bowl. Did FSU deserve to be there, sure did. Did the committee fit the narrative to support their pick…yep. Did they get it mostly right? Yep, but WU should be replaced with Georgia.

[Bill2e]

Basketball / Baseball not even kind of a comparison. I can find JUCO’s in Cali / Texas / Fl that will hurt a lot of teams feelings. They put two dismal performances while wins on tape with no chance of Travis returning. The rankings frankly don’t matter after 4 and FSU got probably if we’re being honest the 1 or 2 seed in a bowl. Did FSU deserve to be there, sure did. Did the committee fit the narrative to support their pick…yep. Did they get it mostly right? Yep, but WU should be replaced with Georgia.

If they were going with eye test, yes

They once again sent a mixed message.

[Meadows]

Basketball / Baseball not even kind of a comparison. I can find JUCO’s in Cali / Texas / Fl that will hurt a lot of teams feelings. They put two dismal performances while wins on tape with no chance of Travis returning. The rankings frankly don’t matter after 4 and FSU got probably if we’re being honest the 1 or 2 seed in a bowl. Did FSU deserve to be there, sure did. Did the committee fit the narrative to support their pick…yep. Did they get it mostly right? Yep, but WU should be replaced with Georgia.

At least if that was the case they wouldn't have to lie to our face and tell us they put the best 4 teams in. I'd still be unhappy about it, but at least they wouldn't be hypocritical, which is why most people think it's a joke.