Brandon, my 2021 Merc 150 4S also will hit single-digit water pressure values in the 3.5"-4" PTP in certain water conditions so my experience mirrors yours. I run it on a 6" manual plate and only get those lower PSI readings while trimmed up of course. I use VVL for readings. The regular 150 4S does not have the lower water pickups of the Pro XS 4S version. I found a prop after testing many that runs well and hits my max WOT rpm within a PTP range that allows me to get adequate water pressure.
The Tempest Plus was the worst prop on my hull. Others love their Tempest. You might find a prop that does more of what you want but testing is the only way to know.