Mediocre at best. Too many penalties, dropped passes, missing open receivers by Brady, fumbles. The entire key to the game was an off side penalty on the Pat's linebacker on the Giants last drive that ended up going from a punting situation to then third and 2 which the Giants converted and then marched on down the field to close the game out. It was clear however who the best QB was in this game, Eli owned Brady! At crunch time Brady missed wide open receivers and couldn't get it done, where Manning consistently hit covered wide receivers, even if they were double teamed he dropped those passes in the tightest window.