OK, I got a look at the prop today and it looks fine. The rubber hub looks like it has shrunk end to end as compared to another prop that I looked at but it was not the exact same prop either. Since I do not have a spare prop, I'm going to buy a new one and have this one rehubbed to serve as my spare after I have it looked at by someone else. The biggest thing that bothers me is that I never saw a decrease in speed or increase in RPMs like I would expect for a "slipping" hub.

Any suggestions for a new prop? I have been considering a 27 TXP. My boat is a Blazer 202 with a 225 HPDI.