Sounds like to me your running at the right ht if your measuring it all correct . So your running heavy some where . You might be water logged .
Is the bottom of the boat all boogered up ,Skag bent or prop shaft is bent . All these things matter .
I dealt with lower speeds and poor performance under a load. This was after years of running at the same loads and same setup. I tried everything, thinking my props were ok. Finally took them both to be reworked and there it was.
Back to my regular top end and very little loaded speed loss. If you think everything else is right, it’s time to let someone work their magic on the props.
I also agree that the 2.5 doesn’t carry a load like the 3.0. They are great running light, but can fall off quick when loaded.
My answer to your original question would be to not get a diff prop, but to work the 25 Tempest. 26 Tempest are usually not right out of the box. The Fury is a good prop, until it wears the cup at all, then it has no lift.
Tempest is great all around prop and if you tell a prop
shop all the right info, they should be able to add some cup and get you where you need to be. I would prop that motor to run right at 6000 rpm light. That way you are still turning enough when you have a load.
Send the tempest to mark croxton with your numbers. He'll make it work. Night and day difference in the 2 I've sent him..
Check your prop slip numbers. Prop slip% = 100 - 100( Actual speed (GPS)/Theoretical speed)
Theoretical speed = RPM x Prop Diameter/Gear Ratio x 1056
Using your numbers, we get 5900 x 25/1.87 x 1056 = 147,500/1974.72 = 74.6
Prop Slip% = 100 - 100 x (66.8/74.6) = 100 - 100 x (.895) = 100 - 89.5 = 10.5%
10.5% slip is not too bad on a bass boat. If you can turn a 26 prop to 6000rpm, your speed would be ~ 71 mph assuming you keep 10.5% prop slip. I know the numbers are not gospel, but you can get a good idea of how your boat is performing with different props. PM me if the calculations don't make sense.
2019 721 ProXs 4S 250
2B599739