Here is the Culprit..... I thought this heavy duty hub was supposed to be solid... I guess not.
05 250 XS/Sportmaster. Carrier looks ok I think. The seal wasnt't damaged so it didn't get that deep into the carrier.I am very worried about the threads on the inside of the housing. The prop cut a good chunk of the retainer nut out so I'm not sure if ther is sufficient threads left to install a new nut.