If it were you....
I see a 2019 Ranger Z185 w/ 150 Pro XS with 20 hours for 32,300
the other a 2017 Z518 w/ 150 regular four stroke with 90 hours for 31,000
Both just have factory options.
Wasn't sure if the little upgrade on the older one was the better option or the lower hours on the newer one was the way to go.
z518 is a step up in quality and design. the z185 was basically a stratos boat from what I have heard. nice boat just not as fancy
2022 z519 cup 225 merc 4s ser # 3B210484. 2--hds12 live units. 2 poles, atlas plate, ghost, hamby's, active target, merc digital gauges
2002 basscat pantera 3 (dad bought new) sold 8-2-22
2000 stratos 20 ss (bought new) 200 hp Rude ficht great boat/motor sold 11-21
pulled by a 2500HD Denali
proud dad of an ARMY Captain
MAGA
ASE/GM Master tech before tools
2017 518 if they are both in comparable condition. In my opinion the 518 is one of the best boats Ranger builds for the weekend angler. Well optioned out, it’s a rocket if you ever want to go to a 200HP and it’s very well designed with the 150.Originally Posted by WildmanWilson
The Z185 is a decent starter boat but it’s very stripped down.
2019 Ford F-150 Platinum (3.5EcoBoost/10spd)
**Listed FOR SALE**2014 Ranger Z119C w/ Evinrude ETEC 225HO Running Croxton’s Razor 4XL 25P
Helix 12 Mega G2N’s with Ultrex
Think like a fish, no matter how weird it gets
Another vote for the Z518.
2022 Ranger Z520R | 2022 Platinum F250
Apex 19 | (2) Apex 16's | Mega 360 | Mega Live
I’m bias I have a 518. Very nice rig. But it’s going to be underpowered with 4s 150. Different boat with a 200 set up rite
I thought the two boats were the exact same hull with a different cap? What other upgrades does it have others than fenders? Yeah a 200 would be nice but the bump in money is substantial. They both weigh the same so a 250 should be the same on both. I hear people say they are under powered but what’s that mean? Is it just top end is 8-10 slower? I’m not a speed demon. Heck, I fish with a buddy in his old Ranger that’s 17 ft and has a 125 on it. He’s 400 pounds and the little boat rides great. He only goes 30 to 35 mostly. And we fish Ky Lake in it.
I’m not a tournament fisherman so I don’t care if it takes me a few extra minutes to go to the next bay. I want a reliable boat that I can pay cash for and use it in my retirement years. But if y’all know of a great deal with the 200 I’m all in. Lol.
The 150 propped right sounds like you. With a 200 it feels more like a sports car. More lift and the boat feels light. You don’t have to go wide open to enjoy it. I cruise at 4k a lot
518 for me
I'd pick the Z518.................with a 200 please Bob.
2017 Phoenix 819
2016 200ProXS, s/n 2B359849, Mod 1200P73BD
Folks saying the Z518 w/ 200, the years he mentioned were not rated for the 200, only the 150. They changed to 200 in 2020, wish I would have waited 1 more year. AHAHAHAHAH
If you couldn't tell, I also own a Z518. This of the Z185 as a starter rig. The trailer is different, the seats are different, the compartment details are different, the drivers controls / cockpit are different.
The 2017 Z518 is prior to the L boat change, so it will be similar in layout to the C boats. Where the 2019 Z185 will look closer to L model.
Been fishin' since I was 5 years old...Thanks Grandpa!
Not true. My 98 518 dvs is rated for a 200
Agreed. I have a 2013 z518 rated for a 200
Respectfully,
Captain Rab
V1CO 1:27 But God has chosen the foolish things of the
world to put to shame the wise; and God has
chosen the weak things of the world to put to
shame the things which are mighty
Between those 2 boats I would choose the Z518 w/ 4 stroke, but I would never buy a boat without having the max HP.
Dawnpatrol.
Goin Fishing be home for Hunting Season !!!!!!!!!
There were a couple of years that the Z518 was rated for 150
My understanding is the Z518 C were rated at 200, the non C / L boats were only 150. If I'm off base, I apologize and will learn something new from y'all.
Been fishin' since I was 5 years old...Thanks Grandpa!
This is correct. When I purchased my 518 new in 2017 the z185 was just released, it has the same hull but different top cap and overall fit and finish uses cheaper materials along with the trailer not being as fancy. In 2017 the z518c was rated for a 200hp and the z518 and the z185 were only rated for a 150. Very frustrating being that all three boats use the exact same hull and having a G2 I may face the reality of having to repower someday and I would really prefer a 200hp or a 175hp at the very least, this is for top end speed only. As far as performance I can't speak for the 4s Mercury, but I have never had any performance issues with my 150HO g2. Hole shot is always excellent even when fully loaded with fuel, live well and partner and when light it really is a rocket to about 50 and then tops out at 60 on a good day and 55-57 loaded up. If you plan on keeping this boat then I think it is really your choice, but I will say that the 518 would probably hold more value and be an easier sell down the road based on its reputation.
2017 Ranger 518 w/ Evinrude 150HO G2
I have a 2019 Ranger 518L with 200Proxs warranty through '27 loaded out I have on market up and down to sell in NC if you are interested... Text me if you are 919-725-two six two zero
Pro's Choice Marine has a brand new Z185 for $34,900.
2021 Skeeter ZX150
2020 Sea Doo GTI se 170
I have a 2018 Z185 because you can store it in a 20'10" garage straight back. If I am not getting a 200 on the 518, I would get the Z185 with the PROXS over a non pro 4 stroke!
The 518 is underpowered so not that one, if it had a 200 yes. Of those choices I would go with Z185.
Reply With Quote
