I like the Dobyns Champion XP 704CB up to 3/8oz and a 705CB for crankbaits over 3/8oz
I'd ordinarily agree, but I think that throwing down to 1/4 oz and in close quarters the X-10 would do a great job, and I feel it could handle the 5/8 as long as we're not talking about deeper divers. As long as he's not fishing around grass, anyhow. I would agree with the X-11 if 1/4 was very rarely being thrown and he was throwing 3/8-5/8 way more often. I think you'll be really pleased with the X-11 as a general purpose cranking rod, by the way!
Obviously everyone has different thoughts on what sticks do what well...makes getting recommendations tough!
2011 Skeeter ZX225
225 Yamaha HPDI Series 2
Minn Kota Ultrex 112 52"
Console: HDS 16 Carbon
Bow: HDS 12 Carbon, Solix 12 G2, Mega 360, Garmin 106 SV, LVS 34
Kistler blade\buzz/chatter great for squarebills
hate it for chatter baits but it’s great for squarebills
I tried throwing 1.5's with the X-10 and just found it way too light. Mainly, I just couldn't get good hook penetration. As we know, we almost exclusively fish vegetation...so that's a factor as well. Like you say, everyone has different likes/dislikes. I generally fish a little heavier on crankbaits. And most "crankbait" rods ate way too soft. If you can't bury the hooks through bone, you're losing fish. My fishing partner uses a flippin stick gor crankbaits...I can't recall the last time I saw him have a bait pull out of a fishes mouth!
The X-10 might be good if you throw cranks on braid, which I do not. Only topwater.
I bought a rebellion, the one you suggested. I love it. You’ve described it perfectly And it will be a very versatile rod in my lineup. I crank a lot. If I were looking some thing that bends just a little deeper into the blank or perhaps was a half power lighter, what would you suggest?
-Matt
Thank you! I'm glad it worked out for you. The slightly deeper flexing slightly less powerful rod you want now is the Megabass P5 Z-Crank Elseil - this one is an incredible lighter powered treble hook moving bait rod.
.
-Matt