Long story short - new boat to me. The livewell pumps did work when I got the boat. The wiring was a complete mess. I put 2 new pumps and cleaned up the wiring (key phrase - Cleaned up the wiring). I identified the 4 wires that led to the 2 pumps. I identified the wires using my meter for each livewell pump switch on the console. I hooked up to the pumps and only one works. I tested the pump by connecting direct to the battery and it work.
I'm getting 14v with the switch on, at the connection point for the pump wiring...however when I connect the pump wiring the pump does not work.