Day'um!!!!!!! I ain't never been called a "guru" or "fine".
The short answer to your question is 'yes', your pad has some SERIOUS issues ....... and I whole heartedly believe this is what's causing your issues.
It should be relatively flat, and relatively smooth (with exception to the centerline weld). Keep in mind that you do not want that weld to be excessive, but you don't want to grind it down smooth either. Some in the past would use a material to fill in and shape their pad to make it perfectly smooth (think of it like fiberglass or body filler ...... but I can't for the life of me remember what it was called). Generally when people are having prop slip issues and/or plowing issues with a hyperlift hull, it's b/c of excessive welds along the centerline (generally causes slip due to aeration), and/or the transom to running surface transition (thus causing a wedge and forcing the nose down).
Your hull has seen some serious wear/tear/repair in it's past. It appears that you have a massive 'hook' in your pad. That Hook is what's causing your nose to plow. It could also be adding to the prop slip as well. Also, that 'tunnel' is definately not suppose to be there, and to be honest scares the heck out of me, making me wonder what happened and how did whomever try to fix it. Just to be 100% honest with you, I've walked away from hyperlifts that had hull issues not as severe as yours. Moving forward and how to correct it properly, I would search the internet for the above mentioned 'filling in-&-smoothing' method OR find a great aluminum repair place and turn them loose (just know that's $$$). There was a guy on here that had a red X19 w/ 2.6L HPDI 200 that did this (the 'filling in-n-smoothing' process). For the life of me I can't remember his screen name. The most cost efficient option is the other option and that is to just live with it. As long as the boat does not leak, catches fish,and you're good with that, then just roll with it. ....... but who buys a X19/200 to watch 150's pass them all day ...... not I.
Side note ...... here's a few of my Xpress projects from years gone by. Miss that first one and my X19 some. ....... I guess that's where/why I sometimes sound like I've been there with these aggravating azz things. LOL
The First Love Affair Project
http://www.bbcboards.net/showthread.php?t=93730
H50 DB Project
http://www.bbcboards.net/showthread.php?t=312937
X19 Project
http://www.bbcboards.net/showthread.php?t=547323
Good Luck man!!!!
Hope it Helps.
-391v