I have owned most of these rods over the last 10 years or so. Love my Loomis rods. Dobyns balance great but I cant seem to feel as much with them. The St Croix are also great built rods But just never did it for me. The Kistlers are close to the Loomis rods in feel but when the two I broke in one year were replaced they were sent down the road. My vote is to Buy a Loomis NRX in the weight range you need and give it a shot. The NRX 893, 873, and 894 are some of my favorites.